The Media Eldorado – Quo Vadis

The Disney-Reliance merger signals a transformative shift in the Indian media landscape, raising questions about consolidation, innovation, and regulatory oversight, writes Pande

e4m by Atul Pande
Published: Feb 29, 2024 9:10 PM  | 5 min read
atul pande
  • e4m Twitter

So the Disney – Reliance merger is inked eventually . It did not come as a surprise as Disney was unable to live with the uncertain nature of the Indian market. Hanging their hat on digital revenues , and be willing to wait to make them happen in emerging markets , has never been the cup of tea of Global corporations. And with the xenophobia surrounding the Indian media business currently, its probably just as well , that a leading Indian business group guides the premier media corporation in the world , in potentially the largest and the most exciting media landscape the world will see over the next few years.

The pricing of the deal surprised me . It’s priced too cheap , if I may say so . Of course , Disney probably doesn’t care as at 30 % plus share holding in the combined entity, its on the bullet train for the ride. Even if it one compares it to a completely depleted ZEE ( market cap 15000 crs ) , and a very well run company Sun TV ( market cap 25000 crs ) , this behemoth looks very attractively priced . In fact , the whole media business in India looks very very attractively priced for any one . My estimate is that the media business in the US is probably valued at a trillion dollars across various companies ( and it is probably a conservative estimate as its difficult to value the tech companies overhang in this space ) , and at these numbers , the Indian market is valued at 2-3 % of the US market when it has 20 % of the world’s consumers!! Does it make sense ?? It doesn’t to me , and I will watch this space with much interest, as an Industry man , and as an investor.

Apart from the financial metrics of the deal , I think its an important pitstop for the industry. In a fundamentally creative business , is such consolidation required . Size usually slows innovation, and are we at a stage to let that happen ? Does this require a regulatory oversight , will this stifle new start ups , and how will the competition react , and will this create a completely new vertical of Creative Delivery vis – a- vis the humongous platforms which are emerging , are some of the questions I grappled with as I watched this merger happen .

With 300 million people who stream content on their devices , and this number expected to grow at upwards of 10 % per annum , we are now the second largest digital market in the world . With such an explosion in viewing minutes, its interesting that the industry still struggles for digital revenues, but I guess the strategy has been to drive penetration and worry about pricing later . And therein lies the opportunity, as the addiction and the fix required to satisfy the demand will drive digital revenues as never before. Think about it , if 300 million people started paying a 1000 Rs a year across digital platforms for basic access at a price which is less than half of cable pricing, we have essentially created a cable revenue system in India on digital , and if we started adding the premium viewing , and On Demand viewing , we are probably looking at significant larger numbers. What is even more exciting is the advertising and influencing opportunity around this , where the sheer nature of the product brings so many more companies who can spend money more effectively , and we see a very cogent ecosystem. Cricket and Television which were able to service 200 and 2000 customers only , will suddenly be replaced by the 20000 and more who focused on reaching their customers through print and outdoor . The pace of change will be dynamic , too dynamic , and expect action from tech , telecom and social media around this space of an accelerated nature.

The emergence of the less than two minute content slot on platforms has created an opportunity for them to collaborate massively , and also creates immense opportunities to them start testing their own platforms for the longer durations . The penny is going drop very quickly on this , and I watch this with interest .

The regulatory environment will also be the one to watch . Will the governments allow this untrammeled growth of platforms and consolidations of this nature . The tech platforms’ gargantuan reach , and connect with their clients leads one to believe that some kind of regulation may be underway. How does one regulate it without having access to confidential data , and conversely , how do customers respond when they are aware that the eye in the sky is beholden to share their viewing records with regulators. Even in the Indian space , with this merger being affected , there are very few large players left , and at least two of them were talking of an acquisition till some time ago . That may still happen , or may happen with some other knights , the fact remains that for a country of our size , and with the content consumption appetite we possess , there are still too few players in the game . The telecom companies will also get invested in this , and platform access may drive choices which is the other unknown in the mix, particularly with the particular affiliation of this merger with at least one platform.

In the interim , lets enjoy the content and services on offer , and as investors do get invested in this space. Its poised for great performance , and hopefully great returns. The much anticipated and promised media El Dorado may finally be here !!

Published On: Feb 29, 2024 9:10 PM